The Cover Art Quest: Bringing Ash and Beckett to Life (and Why I’m Doing Two Covers)

If you’ve been following my writing journey lately, you know that I’ve officially decided to bypass the traditional publishing gatekeepers and take full creative control of His Defiance. Stepping into the indie space is thrilling, but it immediately throws you into the deep end of the absolute biggest decision an author has to make: The Cover.

I knew from day one exactly what I didn’t want. In the M/M romance and romantasy space, it’s incredibly easy to fall into the trap of covers that rely heavily on photomanipulation. You know the ones—the heavily edited stock photos that end up looking a little lifeless, or the covers that lean into overly fetishized tropes that just don’t fit the actual heart of the story.

His Defiance is a chaotic blend of blinding divine light and pitch-black cosmic horror. It’s got gritty, LitRPG-inspired action, but at its core, it’s driven by the intense, protective dynamic between Ash and Beckett. I needed a cover that captured their distinct size difference—Beckett as the lean, tattooed, fiercely defiant survivor, and Ash as the towering, devoted celestial warrior. I wanted a bespoke, fully hand-painted illustration that captured their exact chemistry.

And, above all else, I had a strict, non-negotiable rule: absolutely no generative AI.

The hunt for the right artist was daunting. I spent days scouring the depths of Instagram, battling the algorithm to find illustrators who were actually taking commissions. I combed through ArtStation portfolios, looking for someone who could nail human anatomy, dramatic lighting, and that specific dark fantasy vibe without charging game-studio prices. There were moments of serious doubt where I wondered if my vision was just too specific.

But as I was hunting for the main cover, I realized something else: I didn’t want just one cover.

I’ve decided to go with a dual-cover strategy! Alongside the illustrated character art, I’m commissioning a “discreet” alternate cover. For the discreet version, I want to lean entirely into the symbolism of the world—no human characters, just pure cosmic horror and ethereal aesthetics. I’m visualizing a pristine, bone-white Sandhill crane skull drowning in writhing dark-purple tentacles and abyssal feathers, with violent, searing rays of dawn-light slicing through the darkness behind it. It’s going to be heavy on atmosphere and elegant typography.

After obsessively searching, comparing styles, and refining exactly what Ash and Beckett need to look like, I finally had a “holy grail” moment. I found an absolutely incredible artist who perfectly matches the vibe I’m going for. Even better, they operate through Reedsy, which means the whole process is vetted, professional, and entirely secure.

The project brief is written, the references are gathered, and the game plan is officially locked in. I am beyond excited to step into the art director role and finally see these two unhinged, beautiful characters brought to life visually.

The journey to publication is moving from the planning phase into execution, and I can’t wait to share the visual progress with you all.

What kind of covers are you all drawn to right now? Do you love seeing the characters front and center, or are you team discreet/symbolic covers? Let me know!

Leave a Reply